How is a motion for severance used in Georgia criminal defense?

How is a motion for severance used in Georgia criminal defense?

A severance separates charges or defendants into different trials. In Georgia the rules differ for each, and the judge’s decision is largely discretionary.

Co-defendants. O.C.G.A. § 17-8-4 says that when two or more defendants are jointly indicted for a capital offense, any one can elect a separate trial unless the state waives the death penalty. In other cases, the judge decides. A defendant must show clear prejudice, on factors such as:

  1. Whether the number of defendants creates confusion;
  2. Whether evidence against one may be considered against another despite instructions;
  3. Whether the defenses are antagonistic.

Antagonistic defenses alone aren’t sufficient. A co-defendant’s confession that names the other can’t come in at a joint trial without cross-examination, under Bruton v. United States (1968).

Charges. Georgia’s Supreme Court treats offenses joined only because they’re similar in character as subject to severance as of right. If they’re part of a single scheme or series of connected acts, the judge has discretion, and asks whether a jury could fairly consider each one.

Timing. A motion should come before trial, within the § 17-7-110 window where possible, and be renewed if prejudice develops. A later motion may be denied as waived.

Trade-offs. Severance can mean two trials, and the second trial benefits from a transcript of the first. One defendant might be able to call the other, if the other no longer has Fifth Amendment exposure, which can be a reason for filing. A judge may ask for a proffer of what the co-defendant would say.

General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *