How does a Georgia criminal defense attorney challenge eyewitness testimony?
Eyewitness testimony is challenged before trial through the identification procedure, and at trial through cross-examination, experts, and instructions. Georgia’s Supreme Court has acknowledged the science, disapproving a “level of certainty” jury charge in Brodes v. State (2005), and leaving experts to the judge’s discretion in Johnson v. State (2000).
Before trial. A motion can argue the procedure was impermissibly suggestive, under Neil v. Biggers (1972), with five reliability factors:
- Opportunity to view;
- Degree of attention;
- Accuracy of prior description;
- Certainty;
- Time between event and identification.
O.C.G.A. § 17-20-2 requires written lineup policies for agencies. Perry v. New Hampshire (2012) limits this constitutional test to police-arranged situations.
At trial.
| Issue | Example |
|---|---|
| Viewing | Distance, lighting, time |
| Stress | A weapon drew the witness's attention |
| Description | Height, clothes, and hair versus the real person |
| Time | Weeks later |
| Exposure | News, social media, or a mug shot |
| Cross-racial | Witness and person of different races |
| Bias | Under § 24-6-622 |
Prior ID. Section 24-8-801(d)(1)(C) lets an earlier identification in, if the witness testifies and is subject to cross.
Corroboration. The state’s case gets stronger if there’s something else, like a fingerprint or phone location. The defense’s challenge is strongest when an ID stands alone.
Experts. Testimony covers memory and perception, not whether this witness is right. A judge has discretion.
Cross-examining an honest witness works best when it shows that the witness can be sincere and still mistaken.
General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.