Look for a structural problem, or a tree in decline, combined with something it could hit. Those two together can push the decision toward removal, and either one alone may have other options.
Walk around the tree and check:
| Part | Warning sign | Urgency |
|---|---|---|
| Base | Soil heaving, roots lifted or cut | High if it's new |
| Base | Mushrooms, conks, soft wood | Possible decay; ask soon |
| Trunk | Deep vertical crack, large cavity | Ask soon |
| Trunk | New lean | High |
| Crown | Large dead limbs | Keep people out; ask soon |
| Crown | Thinner than nearby trees, or late to leaf | Watch; ask |
| Limbs | Hanging broken branches | High, if over a target |
| Around it | New construction or trenching near roots | Decline may come later |
Then ask what’s nearby. A house, a driveway, a play area, a street, a line. A tree that’s a low risk in a pasture could be a high risk above a bedroom.
Decide with three options, not one: prune, cable, or remove. An ISA-credentialed arborist can give you a written risk assessment. Ask for the reasoning, as well as a price for each option. A company whose only product is removal may recommend removal.
Before you act:
- Take photos and write the date, particularly if the tree is close to a property line.
- Check your city’s or county’s rules. In the City of Atlanta, even a hazardous tree goes through a permit process.
- Tell your insurer if it’s already storm-damaged.
If you hear cracking or see the lean growing, get everyone out from beneath it and call for help now. That’s not the day to wait for three quotes.