How do Georgia criminal defense attorneys challenge line-up procedures?
The challenge starts with a motion that asks whether the lineup was impermissibly suggestive, under Neil v. Biggers (1972) and Manson v. Brathwaite (1977). If it was, the court asks if the identification is still reliable. Georgia also has a specific statute, O.C.G.A. § 17-20-2, for agency procedures.
Physical versus photo. A physical lineup, after formal charges, brings a right to counsel under United States v. Wade (1967) and Kirby v. Illinois (1972). Georgia’s law also applies to photo arrays, but a right to counsel doesn’t. A lawyer who attends can note how it’s done.
What to attack.
| Issue | Example |
|---|---|
| Fillers | Different height, age, or clothing |
| Show-up | A person alone in a police car, without need |
| Instruction | No warning that the suspect might not be there |
| Administrator | Knows the suspect; gives cues |
| Feedback | "Good job" after choosing |
| Number | Too few people |
| Repeats | Same suspect in multiple rounds |
Show-ups. Georgia allows them shortly after a crime, under the totality test, but they’re inherently suggestive.
Compliance. Section 17-20-3 addresses failure to follow the procedure, and that’s evidence, not an automatic exclusion.
Hearing. The defense asks the officer about each step, with any recording. If the defendant has opted in, discovery under § 17-16-4 should include the lineup record.
Trial. Cross-examination; experts, in the judge’s discretion, under Johnson v. State (2000); the Brodes (2005) point on certainty. Perry v. New Hampshire (2012) limits the constitutional test to police-arranged situations.
General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.