How do Georgia courts evaluate insanity defenses in criminal trials?
Georgia uses two statutory tests, and the defendant bears the burden of proof. O.C.G.A. § 16-3-2 asks whether the person, at the time, “did not have mental capacity to distinguish between right and wrong in relation to such act.” Section 16-3-3 covers a person who, because of mental disease, injury, or congenital deficiency, “acted as he did because of a delusional compulsion as to such act which overmastered his will to resist committing the crime.”
Delusional compulsion. The delusion must be such that if it were true, it would justify the act. A person who believes they must kill because a voice said so doesn’t necessarily qualify, since the delusion wouldn’t justify the killing if real. Someone who thought they were under attack may qualify.
Burden. Sanity is presumed, § 16-2-3. The defense must prove insanity by a preponderance, and a jury may reject expert testimony and rely on lay evidence.
Procedure.
- Notice. Rule 31.5 requires written notice, and under § 17-7-130.1 a court-appointed psychiatrist or licensed psychologist examines the person.
- Trial. Experts for both sides, along with witnesses about the person’s behavior at the time.
- Jury options under § 17-7-131: guilty, not guilty, not guilty by reason of insanity, guilty but mentally ill, and guilty but intellectually disabled, with the required instruction on what each means.
- If NGRI, commitment to a state hospital for evaluation and a hearing under § 17-7-131(d) and (e).
Exclusions. Voluntary intoxication doesn’t count, § 16-3-4(c). A personality disorder may not qualify. Competency to stand trial is a separate question under § 17-7-130.
Insanity isn’t a simple strategy, as the person may be held longer than a sentence would have been.
General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.