How do attorneys argue for dismissal due to lack of probable cause in Georgia?
Lack of probable cause gets raised at the preliminary hearing, and in a motion to suppress for evidence that resulted from the arrest. After an indictment, Georgia courts generally won’t dismiss on this basis.
Stages.
| Stage | Tool | Result if successful |
|---|---|---|
| After arrest | Prompt judicial review, County of Riverside v. McLaughlin (1991) | Release |
| Preliminary hearing | O.C.G.A. § 17-7-23 | Charge dismissed at that level |
| Before indictment | Argument to the prosecutor | Case may be dropped |
| After indictment | Grand jury has found probable cause | Preliminary hearing rights end |
| Warrant affidavit | § 17-5-30 motion; Franks | Suppress fruits |
| Trial | Directed verdict, § 17-9-1 | Acquittal |
Standard. Probable cause means facts that would make a person of reasonable caution believe the person committed a crime. It’s less than proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and a judge uses a practical approach, under Illinois v. Gates (1983).
Preliminary hearing. The defense can cross-examine and call witnesses, but hearsay is allowed, and a judge won’t weigh credibility as at trial. Even if the charge is dismissed, the state can present it to the grand jury.
After indictment. A grand jury’s finding is enough to hold the person for trial, per Gerstein v. Pugh (1975) and related law. So a lawyer should request a hearing before indictment, when it’s possible.
Arrest without probable cause. An illegal arrest doesn’t bar prosecution, but the evidence that flowed from it may be excluded. A later civil claim is possible under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.