How can a Georgia criminal defense lawyer challenge GPS tracking evidence?

How can a Georgia criminal defense lawyer challenge GPS tracking evidence?

A GPS challenge has two main parts: whether the government could get the data without a warrant, and whether the data proves what it’s said to prove.

How it was obtained.

Source Rule
Police tracker on a car Search, United States v. Jones (2012)
Historical cell location Warrant, Carpenter v. United States (2018)
Real-time phone location Warrant, or an emergency
Phone app data from a company O.C.G.A. § 16-11-66.1 process; warrant
Probation ankle monitor May be a condition of the sentence
Vehicle infotainment Warrant if seized from the car
Geofence warrant Particularity is disputed; courts have split

The motion goes under § 17-5-30. Georgia’s constitution can give more protection than the federal one. Without a federal-style good faith exception, under Gary v. State (1992), a defective warrant may lead to exclusion in a way it wouldn’t in federal court.

What it proves.

  • Accuracy. Margin of error, signal loss, urban blockage.
  • Device vs. person. The tracker shows where the device was, not who had it.
  • Time. Time zones and logging intervals.
  • Maps. Software that plots points can give an impression of precision that it doesn’t have.

Foundation. Section 24-9-901(b)(9) covers evidence describing a process or system. The state may also need an expert under § 24-7-702 if it’s interpreting. A cell tower expert’s coverage maps can be challenged.

A private person’s tracker raises other problems, including § 16-11-62(8) where a protective order is in place.

General information about Georgia law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *