It may, and the only way to know is to look at what’s left of the tree’s structure. Broken branches on a sound trunk are a different problem from a split trunk or heaved roots.
| Damage | Direction | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A few broken limbs, trunk sound | Prune and watch | Clean cuts help it recover |
| Weak fork between two stems | Possibly cable or brace | Reduces risk but doesn't make it new |
| Lost bark in a patch | Depends on size | The wider the wound, the harder the recovery |
| Vertical crack through the trunk | Lean toward removal, if near a target | Structure may be compromised |
| Roots lifted, soil heaved | Lean toward removal | The anchor has been lost |
| Large decay cavity near the base | Lean toward removal, if near a target | Hard to judge from outside |
Three cautions apply here. Don’t let a crew “top” a storm-damaged tree, since heavy cuts can create more weak growth, and in the City of Atlanta the Arborist Division’s FAQ says no topping. Don’t paint wounds on advice from a neighbor before asking an arborist. And don’t decide based on how it looks in the first week after a storm, unless it’s a clear danger.
Target matters as much as damage. A cracked tree in the back corner of a large lot may stay under observation, while one above a bedroom can’t. Ask an arborist with a Tree Risk Assessment Qualification to write down what could fail, what it would hit, and what the options are. Then you can get a price for each, including the price of pruning.
If you plan to file an insurance claim, take photographs before any cleanup.